Smartthings vs VeraEdge vs Insteon: Comparison & Reviews

Smartthings-vs-VeraEdge-vs-Insteon-ReviewsSamsung, Vera, and Insteon have one thing in common: all three companies produce Smart Controllers or Smart Switches.

These devices, otherwise known as Smart Hubs, enable customers who have purchased and installed indoor cameras, smart thermostats, advanced HVAC systems, and similar devices, to control all such devices connected to them from a centralized system.

Smartthings by Samsung, VeraEdge by Vera, and Insteon Hub by Insteon are three of the most popular Smart Home controllers on the market today. These three devices have attracted positive customer reviews and will be great for your home.

However, you need to know the differences between Smartthings vs VeraEdge vs InsteonHub. The main difference between them lies in wireless compatibility and third-party integration.

Key Differences between Smartthings vs VeraEdge vs Insteon

  • Capabilities. First of all, let us go through a quick breakdown of the differences in capabilities between these three smart hub controllers. Let’s start with Samsung’s very own smart switch: Smartthings.

This hub is compatible with virtually all of the most widely used smart devices you can think of. However, while it is compatible with Wi-Fi, ZigBee, and Z-Wave protocols, VeraEdge is only compatible with Wi-Fi and Z-Wave. Insteon Hub,  on the other hand, is X-10 Protocol compatible, acts as a repeater, and functions without Wi-Fi.

Although the VeraEdge and Insteon controllers are integration-friendly, they do not support as many devices as Smartthings, which supports over 200 devices. Apart from third-party integration and network compatibility, Bluetooth connectivity is enabled on the Samsung hub but isn’t featured on the other two.

  • Performance. Now that you can tell the differences in capability and design, another equally important thing you should consider is how well they perform. These devices are widely used so it’s fairly easy to get access to customer reviews. We’ve tested them too.

Like we mentioned earlier, the Smartthings Hub is compatible with three of the most popular network protocols: Wi-Fi, ZigBee, and Z-Wave. This means you are able to control your connected smart devices from almost anywhere as long as there is an Internet connection utilizing any of these.

Smartthings is the only battery powered hub of three controllers we are discussing. The other two require a connection to AC power outlets. The average battery life after a recharge is ten hours. It comes with 4 AA batteries. As for Insteon and VeraEdge, it’s obvious that you must have a constant power supply in order to use it.

  • Design. It is unsurprising that design is another area where you can observe differences between these models. They are, after all, designed by different manufacturers. Therefore, there are differences in appearance that may be important to you.

Let’s consider their color and dimensions. Samsung’s Smartthings Hub is white in color, measures 4.9 x 4.2 x 1.3 inches, and weighs eight ounces. VeraEdge by Vera is black in color, measures 4.6 x 3.7 x 1.7 inches, and weighs 12.8 ounces.

Like Smartthings, Insteon Hub comes in white color but is 3.7 x 3.7 x 1.5 in dimension and has a weight of two pounds. White is generic when it comes to smart switches in general but paired with the right design, it is always a good look.

  • Accessories and Price. All three hubs are compatible with Alexa Voice control. In addition to that, they can each be controlled remotely using the iOSand Android applications for Smartthings, Insteon, and VeraEdge respectively. All that is required is a compatible wireless connection or IP.

Side by Side Comparison Chart:Smartthings vs Veravs Insteon

Smart Hub ProductSmartthingsVera EdgeInsteon
Dimensions4.9 x 4.2 x 1.3 in4.6 x 3.7 x 1.7 in3.7 x 3.7 x 1.5 in
IFTTT IntegrationSupported Supported Supported
AlexaSupported Supported Supported
RangeOver 200 devices 50-75 devices 50-75 devices
Wi-FiEnabled with router EnabledNot required
BluetoothConnectivityYesNoNo
Operating SystemiOS, Android, Windows iOS and Android iOS and Android
NotificationsYesYesYes
Memory256mb RAMFlash Memory 128mbCloud-based
Battery Backup4 AA BatteriesNoNo
Mobile AppsYesYesYes
Z-Wave and ZigbeeBoth SupportedZ-Wave supportedDual-Mesh Technology
WarrantyOne-year limitedLimitedTwo-year limited
ProblemsWi-Fi requires routerNo BluetoothNo Wi-Fi

Samsung Smartthings Review

Samsung SmartThings
Check Price on Amazon

Samsung’s Smartthing is one of the most popular hubs you can find on the market. That is because it is from a trusted manufacturer and has garnered a lot of positive reviews on the Internet.

It supports virtually any smart home device you can think of. From security cameras to thermostats to Heating and Cooling systems, this device grants you control from a single system.

It is battery powered and affords you the ability to use it with different wireless connections including ZigBee, Z-Wave, and Wi-Fi. If you plan on using it with a wi-fi connection, there must be a wireless router connection. With a 256mb RAM and Bluetooth connectivity, this device able to control your home’s lighting, temperature, and security automation systems.

This device also works with an app that is available on iOS, Android, and Windows devices, which gives you remote access. It comes with a one-year limited warranty. An up to date release supports Apple HomeKit.

Pros
  • Compatible with Wi-Fi as well as Z-Wave and ZigBee devices.
  • Can control over 200 devices.
  • Comes with 4 AA Batteries.
  • The application is available on iOS, Windows, and Android support.
  • Bluetooth LE enabled.
  • Amazon Alexa supported.
Cons
  • Wi-Fi requires router.
  • One-year limited warranty.
Great Read:
Wink 2 vs SmartThings

VeraEdge Review

VeraEdge
Check Price on Amazon

VeraEdge does not come with batteries and must be plugged into an AC power outlet in order for it to function. It is available on the market as a black colored device measuring 4.6 x 3.7 x 1.7 inches and weighing 12.8 ounces. It is equipped with the ability to connect with around 50-75 devices.

The device has a Geofencing feature that is responsive to your proximity to it. It is able to use that information to set all your connected smart home devices to your preferred settings. Unlike the Smartthings hub, this switch does not support ZigBee but is compatible with both Wi-Fi and Z-Wave wireless connections.

VeraEdge does not support Bluetooth connectivity but is able to call on a 128mb memory to help with regulating your thermostats, alarms, sprinklers, camera compatibility, and Veralite. You can download the iOS and Android app for remote control. It is also compatible with Apple HomeKit.

Pros
  • Wi-Fi and Z-Wave compatibility.
  • Remote access from Smartphone app.
  • 128mb Flash memory.
  • Apple HomeKit compatibility.
  • Geofencing technology.
Cons
  • Incompatible with ZigBee.
  • Not Battery Powered.

Insteon Hub Review

Insteon Hub
Check Price on Amazon

Insteon Hub is designed with the same generic white color, which appears on Samsung’s controller but has different dimensions measuring 3.7 x 3.7 x 1.5 inches and weighing 2 pounds. This device, however, has a third-party integration range similar to VeraEdge and can control around 50-75 connected devices.

Like the VeraEdge controller, this is not a battery powered system. It is only able to carry out its functions if it is plugged into an AC power outlet. Like both the Smartthings and VeraEdge hubs, it is compatible with Stringify, Google Assistant, and IFTTT. It is also compatible with Apple HomeKit.

This device is optimized for cloud-based storage and is capable of switching connected lighting controls to set particular customized Scenes. It also comes with an iOS and Android app and a two-year limited warranty.

Pros
  • Compatible with Apple HomeKit for bridge setup.
  • Compatible with IFTTT and Stringify.
  • Can create customized scenes with ambient lighting.
  • Android and iOS application available.
Cons
  • Not Battery Powered.
  • Cloud-storage requires subscription.

Smartthings or VeraEdge or Insteaon – Our Verdict

That is our comparison and review. Smartthings, VeraEdge, and Insteaon Hub are very easy to set up. If you need help you can either contact customer service or consult their manuals.

These three smart hub controllers give you centralized control even when you are away from your home with wireless connectivity.

As far as remote access, third-party integration, local control, and compatible devices are concerned, however, Samsung’s smart switch is the clear winner over the other two competitors. It is best for keeping your home smart and secure.